STEM Club Starter Pack › free package. This page prints cleanly: each sheet starts on a new page. Get 4 more: $19
Heat transfer and insulation
Warm Wool: Which Wrap Keeps the Heat In?
Groups wrap cups of warm tap water in wool and in cotton, read a thermometer every five minutes, and find out what a fleece is really doing for the animal that grows it.
Ages 8 to 10 · 60 minutes · groups of 3 · adult supervision required
What the group will do and learn
- Run a fair test: the same cups, the same amount of water and the same starting temperature, with only the wrap changed.
- Read a thermometer at set times and record the readings in a table.
- Explain a wrap's effect as slowing the flow of heat, using the idea of trapped air.
These packages are drafted with AI assistance and then reviewed: every science statement is checked against a source you can open, every package must pass our hazard rubric before it can be built, and a second, separate review pass looks for errors in the science, the safety steps, the timing and the prices. Adult supervision is required for every session. The adult running the session is responsible for supervising it and for deciding whether it suits the group.
Safety sheet
| Age band | Ages 8 to 10 |
|---|---|
| Adult supervision | Required. One adult for every 12 children, in the room for the whole session. |
| Protective gear | None needed |
| Checked against | Hazard rubric version 0.1, on 22 November 2026 |
| Hazard class | Present or absent | Where it occurs | Control |
|---|---|---|---|
| Heat | Present. Ordinary supervision is enough with the control shown. | Setting up: warm tap water is poured into the cups. | Warm tap water only, never from a kettle. An adult checks it with a thermometer first: no warmer than 40 degrees Celsius (104 degrees Fahrenheit). An adult does all the pouring. |
| Sharps | Present. Ordinary supervision is enough with the control shown. | The thermometer has a pointed probe. | Children hold it by its body, seated, and never walk around with it. |
| Chemicals | Present. Ordinary supervision is enough with the control shown. | The whole test: cups of plain tap water. | Tap water only, nothing added. Nobody drinks from the cups. |
| Batteries and lithium cells | Present. Ordinary supervision is enough with the control shown. | Measuring: each digital thermometer holds button cells. | An adult checks beforehand that every battery cover is closed. Thermometers are counted out and back in. |
| Lasers | Absent | ||
| Small parts | Present. Ordinary supervision is enough with the control shown. | Setting up: rubber bands hold the wraps on. | Count the rubber bands out and back in. They stay on the cups and are not flicked. Not for anyone who mouths objects. |
| Allergens | Present. Ordinary supervision is enough with the control shown. | Setting up and clearing away: children handle wool. | Ask beforehand whether any child reacts to wool or lanolin. That child handles the cotton and bare cups and does the recording. Everyone washes hands at the end. |
| Electrical | Absent | ||
| Combustion | Absent | ||
| Projectiles | Absent | ||
| Moving and falling objects | Absent |
Also keep in mind
- Water on a hard floor is a slip hazard. Stand the cups on a tray or towel and wipe spills at once.
- Groups sharing a thermometer sit side by side and pass it by its body. It is never carried.
- The cups listed are sold for cold drinks. That is one reason the water is only warm; hot water is never used.
Adult supervision is required for every session. The adult running the session is responsible for supervising it and for deciding whether it suits the group.
Shopping list
Worked out for a club of 12 working in groups of 3 (4 groups). Buying every line new comes to $39.46, which is $3.29 per student rounded up. Check what the club already owns before buying. Most of it can be used again.
| What you need | Example product | Buy | Price each, as read | Line total | Substitute |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Digital thermometer, one between two groups | ThermoPro TP01AW Digital Meat Thermometer at Target | 2 | $9.99 read ; out of date after | $19.98 | Any thermometer that reads 10 to 50 degrees Celsius. |
| Cotton washcloth, one per group | Room Essentials Everyday Washcloths, 18 pack at Target | 1 | $8.50 read ; out of date after | $8.50 | Any clean cotton cloth about as thick as the wool wrap: a sock, or a tea towel folded once. |
| Plastic cups, three per group | Dealworthy Clear Disposable Cups, 9 fl oz, 80 count at Target | 1 | $3.99 read ; out of date after | $3.99 | Any three cups, mugs or jars that match each other. |
| Rubber bands, four per group | up&up Rubber Bands, assorted, 300 count at Target | 1 | $6.99 read ; out of date after | $6.99 | String, hair ties or tape. |
We sell no physical goods. Links to suppliers are plain links, not endorsements, and we are paid nothing for them. Prices are as read on the supplier's page on the date shown; they change, and can differ by store and region. A price is treated as out of date 30 days after it was read: check the supplier’s page before you rely on it.
You also need (not in the total)
- Warm tap water: about 200 ml for each cup, three cups per group
- One clean wool item per group as a wrap: a sock, hat or scarf, or wool yarn wound round the cup. Raw fleece or alpaca fibre from a farm also works, inside a thin sock
- Kitchen foil, for a lid on every cup
- A jug for the adult, a timer everyone can see, and a tray or towel per group
Facilitator guide
The activity in three pictures
Label three matching cups. Wrap one in a cotton cloth and one in wool, the same number of layers, with two rubber bands each. Leave the third bare.
An adult pours the same amount of warm tap water into each cup. Press a foil lid on each, with a small hole for the thermometer.
Read every cup at the start and at 5, 10, 15 and 20 minutes. Take the last reading from the first: the smallest drop kept the most heat in.
Before the session
- Try the test yourself the day before with the same cups, wraps and thermometers, so you know what size of difference to expect.
- Print one handout per child: Level A for most 8 and 9 year olds, Level B for children ready to subtract decimals and draw a line graph.
- Check every thermometer reads in degrees Celsius and has its battery cover closed. In one cup of water they should agree to within about a degree.
- Set out for each group: three matching cups, one cotton cloth, one wool wrap, four rubber bands and three squares of foil.
- Run the warm tap until it is steady, check it is no warmer than 40 degrees Celsius, and fill a jug just before the groups are ready.
0 to 5 min: What is a fleece for? (5 min)
- Hold up the wool. Ask: a sheep or an alpaca stands outside all winter. What is its fleece doing? Does wool make heat? Write the guesses on the board.
- Set the question: does a wrap change how fast warm water cools, and does it matter what the wrap is made of?
5 to 15 min: Set up a fair test (10 min)
- Each group labels its cups: no wrap, cotton, wool.
- Wrap the cotton round one cup and the wool round another, the same number of layers, with two rubber bands each.
- Ask what has to stay the same for a fair test: the cups, the amount of water, the starting temperature, the place on the table.
- An adult pours the same amount of warm water into every cup. Children press on a foil lid with a small hole for the thermometer.
15 to 35 min: Measure (20 min)
- Straight away, read each cup and write it under Start. Hold the probe in the middle of the water and wait until the number stops changing.
- Roles: one reads, one writes, one keeps time. Swap after each round.
- Read all three cups again at 5, 10, 15 and 20 minutes, in the same order; the second group a minute later.
- Between readings, feel the outside of each cup and wrap. Which feels warmest? What does that say about where the heat is going?
35 to 45 min: Work out the result (10 min)
- For each cup, subtract the 20 minute reading from the start reading. That is the drop.
- Put the three cups in order, smallest drop first.
- Write every group's drops on the board. Do the groups agree? Where they do not, what was different?
45 to 55 min: What is happening (10 min)
- Go back to the guesses. Did the wool make heat? No cup got warmer; the wrapped cups only cooled more slowly.
- Use the notes in What is happening: heat flows from the warm water to the cooler room, and trapped air slows it.
- Pull the wool gently apart and hold it to the light. What fills the gaps between the fibres?
- If wool and cotton came out close, what might matter more than the kind of fibre? Listen for thickness and tightness.
55 to 60 min: Clear up and count back (5 min)
- An adult empties the cups into the sink.
- Count the thermometers and rubber bands back in. Everyone washes hands.
What is happening
For the adult. Each statement cites its source, listed at the end.
- Heat is energy moving because of a difference in temperature. It moves from the warmer thing to the cooler thing: here, from the warm water to the cooler room.[1]
- Heat is not something a wrap has. It is energy leaving the warm water because the room is cooler, and a wrap can only slow that.[2]
- Air conducts heat poorly. Good insulators, wool among them, hold many small pockets of air.[3]
- The pockets in fur and fibre are too small for the air in them to circulate and carry heat away, which is why a fleece works even though air on its own would move.[4]
Student handout · Level A: read and compare
Warm Wool
Name Date
Three cups of warm water: one bare, one wrapped in cotton, one wrapped in wool. Which one stays warm longest?
- Label your cups: no wrap, cotton, wool. Wrap two of them.
- Guess which cup will stay warmest. Write your guess.
- When the water is in, press a foil lid on each cup.
- Read each cup now, then at 5, 10, 15 and 20 minutes.
- Take the last number away from the first. That is the drop.
| Cup | Start | 5 min | 10 min | 15 min | 20 min | Drop |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No wrap | ||||||
| Cotton | ||||||
| Wool |
- Which cup had the smallest drop?
- Was your guess right?
- Did any cup get warmer?
- Why does a sheep need a fleece in winter?
Student handout · Level B: measure and graph
Warm Wool: rate of cooling
Name Date
A wrap does not make heat. Find out how much it slows the cooling, and whether the kind of fibre or the thickness matters more.
- Set up three matching cups: no wrap, cotton and wool, with the same number of layers.
- Record each cup's temperature at the start and every 5 minutes for 20 minutes.
- Work out the drop for each cup: start reading minus 20 minute reading.
- Divide the drop by 20 for the average rate of cooling, in degrees per minute.
- Draw a line graph of temperature against time, one line for each cup.
| Cup | Start | 5 min | 10 min | 15 min | 20 min | Drop | Degrees per minute |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| No wrap | |||||||
| Cotton | |||||||
| Wool |
- Which line on your graph is steepest? What does a steep line mean?
- Thermometers can differ by a degree. Is the difference you found between wool and cotton bigger than that?
- What would you change to test whether thickness matters more than the kind of fibre? What would you keep the same?
Assessment rubric
For the adult. Use it to notice what each child can do; it is not a test.
| Criterion | Getting started | On the way | Secure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Fair testing | Sets up three cups but with different amounts of water or layers. | Keeps cups, water and layers the same, with reminders. | Keeps everything but the wrap the same without reminders and can say why. |
| Measuring | Reads the thermometer before the number has settled, or misses readings. | Takes every reading on time and records it in the right box. | Takes every reading the same way each time and notices a reading that looks wrong. |
| Using results | Says which cup was warmest without using numbers. | Works out the drop for each cup and puts the cups in order. | Compares the size of the drops and says whether a difference is big enough to trust. |
| Explaining | Says wool is warm. | Says the wrap slows the heat leaving the cup. | Explains that trapped air slows the flow of heat and links it to an animal's fleece. |
If something goes wrong
- Wool and cotton give almost the same drop.
- That is a real result, not a mistake. Both wraps hold small pockets of air, and air conducts heat poorly. Compare the thickness of the two wraps, and try the first extension.
- All three cups cool by only a degree or two.
- The water started too close to room temperature. Use the warmest water the limit allows, and fill the cups at the last moment.
- A group's bare cup stays warmer than its wrapped cups.
- That cup was probably poured last or filled fuller. Ask what was not the same, then rerun with all three poured together.
If there is time left
- Test thickness: wrap two cups in the same material, one with a single layer and one with three, and compare the drops.
Sources
- Heat flows from a hotter body to a colder one. College Physics 2e, section 14.5: Conduction. https://openstax.org/books/college-physics-2e/pages/14-5-conduction, read on .
- Heat is the spontaneous transfer of energy due to a temperature difference. College Physics 2e, section 14.1: Heat. https://openstax.org/books/college-physics-2e/pages/14-1-heat, read on .
- Good insulators incorporate many small pockets of air, and air has poor thermal conductivity. College Physics 2e, section 14.5: Conduction. https://openstax.org/books/college-physics-2e/pages/14-5-conduction, read on .
- Fur and fibre trap air in spaces too small to support convection. College Physics 2e, section 14.6: Convection. https://openstax.org/books/college-physics-2e/pages/14-6-convection, read on .
Sources are cited so you can check them. No source and no supplier reviewed, sponsors or endorses this package.
Four more like this
This package is free. The Club Starter Pack has 4 more in the same format, for $19 one-time. See what is in it.
- Foil Boat Load Challenge: Buoyancy, displacement and density
- Hidden Colours: Marker Chromatography: Mixtures and separation
- Pendulum Timing Lab: Periodic motion and controlled experiments
- Reaction Time: the Ruler Drop: Free fall and the nervous system